Email Security
Review Microsoft 365 Email Threat Protection
Check which email protections your Microsoft 365 plan includes and which policies apply. Decide who handles quarantined mail and messages reported by staff.
Content review: 2026-10-05 · Estimated effort: Medium
Priority and effort are suggestions, not risk scores or deadlines. Check business impact, vendor instructions, licenses and obligations before making changes. Test before wider rollout.
Before you start
Before starting: identify the mail administrator, alert reviewer, and backup contact. Record current policies, licenses, mail gateways, and exceptions. Agree how users report missing or suspicious mail and how the business will recover from a false positive.
Put it into practice
- Start with the Microsoft 365 protections available to cloud mailboxes, including anti-spam, anti-malware, and anti-phishing policies. In the Defender portal, inspect Email & collaboration > Policies & rules > Threat policies. Record each control, its scope, and whether it is included in your actual subscription. Safe Links, Safe Attachments, and some impersonation features depend on Defender licensing; do not assume a free trial is a permanent option.
- Compare your effective policy with Microsoft's Standard preset guidance. The Standard and Strict presets are not assigned to users until an administrator applies them. Check policy precedence and recipient scope before changing anything. If a change is justified, pilot an approved group, document expected behavior, and retain a recovery route. Other mail providers use different settings and entitlements.
- Review broad allow lists, transport-rule bypasses, and third-party gateways that may undermine filtering. Remove unnecessary exceptions in a controlled pilot after confirming dependencies. Do not allow an entire domain simply because one message was incorrectly quarantined; investigate and use the narrowest supported correction.
- Assign quarantine review and alert handling to named people with backup coverage. Check the user-reported message settings and tell staff how to report suspicious or missing mail without interacting with links or attachments. Verify sender context before releasing quarantined content; record decisions and recurring false positives.
- Verify: use benign mail to confirm normal delivery and the user-reporting route. Use only a provider-documented harmless test procedure, with approval and designated test recipients, to check filtering/quarantine behavior. Do not send real malware, collect passwords, or conduct surprise phishing simulations. A delivered ordinary email does not prove threat detection works.
- Record effective policy scope, test outcomes, reviewer, and limitations. If rollout disrupts mail, roll back the scoped change with approval and investigate rather than disabling protection globally. Recheck after license, gateway, or policy changes; even correctly configured filtering cannot catch every malicious message.
Use what you have
Tools and templates
“Included” tools require an eligible product or subscription. Options reviewed 2026-10-05; check current vendor terms.
Start without another software subscription
Review protections included with the actual mailbox subscription, assign quarantine ownership and use the free verification worksheet.
What to account for: Manual review and awareness training do not replace Safe Links, Safe Attachments or other licensed protections. Do not upload confidential mail to public scanning sites as a substitute.
Allow for equipment, storage and staff time. Eligibility details are linked below.
Microsoft Defender preset security policies
Included protections for cloud mailboxes; advanced features require Defender licensing
Open Email & collaboration > Policies & rules > Threat policies > Preset Security Policies. Compare the Standard settings with your current policies and test an approved scope.
Limits: Safe Links, Safe Attachments and advanced impersonation protections are not included in every mailbox subscription. A free trial is not an ongoing free solution.
Your information: Messages and quarantine data are processed by the mail service. Use harmless test mail and keep customer content out of this worksheet.
Official instructions: Microsoft Defender preset security policies ↗Download a working template
Open the Excel or Word file using your existing Microsoft Office license. Replace fictional entries, fill in the blanks and save your own copy. These manual worksheets have no macros, scoring or automatic verification.
- Microsoft 365 email protection review (Excel (.xlsx)) ↓
Record the effective policy, subscription limits, reviewer, and actual result for each email protection or reporting workflow. The example is fictional and untested.
Fictional worksheet preview: Microsoft 365 email protection review Control or workflow Recipient scope Observed result EXAMPLE: anti-phishing review Authorized test mailbox Not tested Three columns shown. The full worksheet also records subscription eligibility, effective settings and next actions. Check your plan before expecting a particular protection.
- Security change and verification record (Excel (.xlsx)) ↓
Plan one scoped change per row, including prerequisites, recovery, test expectations and actual results. An untested change is not a verified success.
Fictional worksheet preview: Security change and verification record Change ID Proposed change Actual test results EXAMPLE-CHANGE-01 Test an approved MFA policy in a limited scope Not tested Three columns shown. The full worksheet also records prerequisites, expected behavior and recovery steps. Confirm permissions and recovery access before making changes.
- Log and alert review record (Excel (.xlsx)) ↓
Give each log or alert a reviewer, response route and tested delivery path. Record a restricted evidence reference rather than copying raw logs.
Fictional worksheet preview: Log and alert review record Log or alert source Primary reviewer role Delivery and event visibility result EXAMPLE-SIGN-IN-ALERT IT owner Not tested Three columns shown. The full worksheet also records backup reviewer coverage, response steps and restricted evidence references. Set review times and test delivery; a worksheet does not provide continuous monitoring.
Fictional worked example
Use these invented entries as a guide when filling in your worksheet. They are not a customer story or lab result. Record what you observe in your own checks.
A small Microsoft 365 team wants to know who reviews quarantine and which anti-phishing policy protects a test mailbox.
Use the Microsoft 365 email protection review template.
What to enter before testing
- Control or workflow
- EXAMPLE: anti-phishing policy
- Recipient scope
- Authorized test mailbox; verify effective policy
- Reviewer and backup
- Assign approved roles
- Observed result
- Not tested
How to verify
Compare the effective policy with the intended licensed protections. Use only provider-documented harmless tests in an authorized scope, then check delivery, quarantine visibility and the reviewer response route. Record which features were actually checked.
If the result is unexpected
If ordinary mail is incorrectly quarantined, investigate the message and policy before making a narrow approved correction. Do not broadly allow-list a domain or release suspicious mail just to pass the exercise. Never use live malware or collect credentials.
Keep completed worksheets private. Leave out passwords, recovery keys and confidential messages. This site does not receive your edits, but a cloud editor or synced folder may send them to its provider.
Sources and review approach
These guides use selected NIST CSF 2.0 alignments. They are not official crosswalks or complete framework implementations. We have not tested these steps in your environment.
- NIST CSF 2.0: PR.PS-01: protective configuration
- NIST CSF 2.0: DE.CM-09: monitoring email content and services
- https://www.nist.gov/publications/nist-cybersecurity-framework-csf-20 ↗
- https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-office-365/preset-security-policies ↗
- https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-office-365/eop-about ↗
- https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-office-365/submissions-user-reported-messages-custom-mailbox ↗